BlackPlastic's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Lucid (demo)]

((VOTED4))

If you ask me its good the way it is. No need to really add anything more substantial. If I were you I'd try to loop the song. Make a nice peacful slow tune that goes on forever. That would make it a really great song for a menu for a game or something like that. You dont really expect to see that great of drums on an ambient song but you were able to go that extra mile and do that so good job for that. Anyways take into account what I said when you do want to finish up this song. I can't wait to hear it.

PS. what was that thing saying?

bearwasdead responds:

Thank you for the vote! I was actually just about to submit the loop version of this, and i knew someone was going to ask about the voice.

Ladies and Gentlemen Liquid Adrenaline

[Energy Drink Time]

((VOTED5))

I thought this song was really great. Like an experimental guitar song. Were you just making things up as you went? Because I really liked the abstrect sound of this though when you do something like this for 3 minutes its kind of hard not to get a bit repetitive so I don't blame you for that. The guitar in the background made a good impact on the song, you probably should of added at least some drums in there though. But anyways it was an overall great guitar song. Good job man.

[Escalation]

((VOTED5))

I thought it was a really great song. I had of diversity going on here. It wasnt just one small piece played over again but had a few good chords being played at different times which really kept things interesting. And its really hard to do what you were doing here without making things seam really chaotic and hard to enjoy but you were able to pull it off great. You knew exactly what to do and what not to do and that was the success of this song. Good job man. Voted 5.

Valtrix responds:

Glad you liked it! This song took a lot of trial and effort. The song really changed direction from when I first started. Still trying to learn the program and how to arrange songs and whatnot. I'm glad you thought there was a lot of diversity--I like to make sure you're not listening to 16 measures of the same thing (I know some people do that :P).

Thanks for the five! Although, the review means more to me than any number of fives you would give me.

[Sonic 2 Battle - With Drums!]

((VOTED5))

I thought this was a really great video game song. It had that feal to it that you would expect on an old video game. And the drums, I think, really made a difference and made it a lot better because no matter how good a song is you can't rely soley on leads. But since you made this song completly the same exept for the drums you expect the drums to be a bit more complex but its good just the way it is so be proud of this song because I thought it was great. Good job.

[The Return to Gaia]

((VOTED5))

Wow dude this was an awsome song. Did you have like a band and effects team working with you or was it all you. The vocals were amazing, slow paced yet still really hardcore which isnt the easiest thing to do. The guitar was played very smoothly and I just loved all the effects and everything. It was a flat out professionally made song. You definantly have a lot of potential as a musician. If I were you Id get the hell off newgrounds and try and make some money off of your talents. Anyways great song. Good job.

Goatchrist responds:

Thanks for the awesome review my friend. I really appreciate it!

It's all me, I do all instruments, drum programming, mixing, etc.

I'm really grateful for all the kind words, I'll post more stuff in the future and I hope you'll like the future stuff just as much ;) I'm also working on a professional pressing of the actual stuff, so I we'll see how far I can get.

[-=sUdJoX=-]

((VOTED1))

Sorry but it wasnt that good. It was very repetitive with few redeaming values. Try and put a few more intruments in the song make it a bit more complex and less repetitive if you want to make it a really good song. And at least you got the loop right in here so try and take that skill and use it in future songs. Anways try and take what I said into use in your next song. I hope to hear some of your new songs in the future.

[Do you know that you're insane]

((VOTED5))

Well it was an overall good and well made song but it really wasnt all good. Like I dont really think it should have been 4 and a half minutes long when there really wasnt much diversity in it. I really did like the synth and effects in this song but just keep it short and simple on your next song because I know there was a lot of potential in this. I just dont think someone is going to listen to a song for 4 minutes unless it was really incredible. Still you have a lot of talent and I hope to hear your next song. Good job.

[blood drunk]

((VOTED5))

I thought this was a really quality song. The vocals are what really made this song for me. But dont get me wrong the guitar was great too but it is really hard to find good singers on newgrounds. But like the other guy said either the guitar overpowered the vocals or the vocals overpowered the guitar. You should really keep everything at a constant volume. But anyways it was a great song, really long and kept my attention throughout. I hope to hear more like this from you.

azserath responds:

yeah its our recording equipment its sucks balls

[MINI LOOP 3]

((VOTED2))

Sorry dude but I wasnt really fealing this song. Way to chaotic. You tryed to overdue it and make a really complex loop but that kind of backfired on you and made it really hard to enjoy. But you really did have the basis of what could be a good song if you tryed to keep things a bit more simple. Also it wasnt really a loop. More like a really short song. Try not to give your song any assemblance of an intro when trying to make a loop because that ends up completly throwing everything off. But anyways I think there was a lot of potential in this song so keep on trying until you make something really good.

[Grind Down]

((VOTED4))

I liked this song. Had some really nice guitar and some awsome drumbs. It didnt really keep a constant motion though. Its like sometimes it was really cool sometimes it was boring sometimes it was so-so. If you asked me the intro and the outro were incredibly boring. I know you want to keep it slow and ease into the song but just drums and nothing else is a little much. Also the guitar could have been a little more complex. Just the same small chord over and over again. But still it was a pretty entertaining song. Probably better as a loop then a whole song but its still good this way. I hope to see more peices from you soon.

High-off-cheese responds:

ya, I'm a drummer so I focused on the drums mostly